Bochum-Grenoble-Taipei Memory Colloquium
2024

This virtual colloquium series focuses on topics in the philosophy of memory and related philosophical areas, but reaches out also to philosophically interested researchers in the cognitive sciences. The colloquium is organized by the Centre for Philosophy of Memory at Université Grenoble Alpes (Kourken Michaelian and Nikola Andonovski), the Ruhr-Universität Bochum (Markus Werning and Sofiia Rappe), and the Institute of Philosophy of Mind and Cognition at the National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University (Ying-Tung Lin and Chris McCarroll).

Please join the meetings on Zoom with the details below. Registration is not necessary.


Andy Hamilton
(Durham University)
Memory-reports and dream-narratives: Are dreams events in sleep?
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 16 April 2024

Abstract: Dreaming is a strangely neglected topic in philosophy, despite the use to which Cartesian sceptics have put it. This paper compares dream-narratives with memory-reports, arguing against the Analytic and popular consensus that the former are not memory-reports – there are vital differences as well as similarities. As Wittgenstein recognised, dream-narratives have authority – memory-reports, in contrast, are merely reliable. As in his account of pain, Wittgenstein rejects both Cartesianism and behaviourism: "Does this mean that it is nonsense ever to raise the question whether dreams really take place during sleep, or are a memory phenomenon of the awakened? It will turn on the use of the question." In this discussion, I am indebted to the work of Roger Squires (1940-2021).


Ali Boyle
(London School of Economics)
The evolution of episodic memory: what are the rules of the game?
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 30 April 2024

Abstract: If episodic memory is an adaptation, what is its evolutionary function? A number of apparently conflicting answers have recently been offered to this question. It is not clear, however, how to adjudicate between these accounts: what should an adequate account of episodic memory's function do? Drawing on critical responses to existing accounts, I consider three prima-facie plausible desiderata on accounts of episodic memory's function. First, functional accounts of episodic memory should specify a selection-relevant benefit that outweighs the costs of episodic memory. Second, functional accounts should explain central, characteristic features of episodic memory, such as autonoetic consciousness. Third, functional accounts should explain the existence of episodic memory and not related but distinct phenomena. Whilst these desiderata all appear reasonable, I argue that they are difficult to justify once we grant the possibility that episodic memory may have developed gradually over a long period of evolutionary time – a possibility we should acknowledge, particularly given the emerging picture of animals' memory capacities. In light of this argument, I attempt to motivate some alternative desiderata for accounts of episodic memory's evolution.


Shin Sakuragi
(Shibaura Institute of Technology)
Memory belief, evidence, and disposition
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 14 May 2024

Abstract: Many of our beliefs were originally acquired based on some evidential grounds, while we often do not remember their original grounds. In this talk, I examine how memory beliefs are justified after their original grounds were lost. In my view, acquiring a new belief and retaining it in memory require maintaining a variety of relevant dispositions, and acceptable theories of justification for memory beliefs have to take the epistemic roles of relevant dispositions into account. In light of the epistemic roles of relevant dispositions, I claim that retaining a once well-grounded belief without having sufficient grounds for it is rather exceptional.


Katsunori Miyahara
(Hokkaido University)
Title TBA
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 04 June 2024

Abstract: TBA


Julia Langkau
(Université de Genève)
Title TBA
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 18 June 2024

Abstract: TBA


Cameron Buckner
(University of Houston)
Title TBA
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 09 July 2024

Abstract: TBA


Daniel D. Hutto
(University of Wollongong)
Title TBA
12:15-13:45 Central European Summer Time (UTC+02:00)/18:15-19:45 Taiwan Standard Time (UTC+08:00), 16 July 2024

Abstract: TBA